I understand that "Ed" may have wanted to sharpen the photogragh and worked on contrast... However, I do prefer the original as it is more natural and the other pic appears too rich in the sense of "too much" red......Perhaps a happy medium would be best???
Great job peter!
Apr 23, 2008 Rating
Just a little too far by: N.G
I like both photos, but I think the best likely falls somewhere between the two pictures.
I like that there is a little bit of blue in the upper left of Peter's version, that gets washed out with the modifications.
So, I like both of them, but think 50:50 is the best approach here.
